Having recently enjoyed Captain America: The Winter Soldier, I felt like revisiting and updating my personal rankings of the Marvel Comics-based films that have been released so far. While The Winter Soldier is, in my opinion, the best film yet produced in-house by Marvel Studios, I cannot quite rank it as the top film in this list alongside films produced by Sony and Fox.
There are several Marvel-based films that I have not yet seen - the Blade, Punisher and Ghost Rider franchises as respective wholes, Elektra, Howard the Duck, the 1990 Captain America film, etc.
Anyway, here is how I rank what I have seen:
1. X2: X-Men United - The most thematically powerful, comprehensively well-made Marvel film.
Highlight - The 'coming out mutant' scene at Bobby Drake (Iceman)'s parents house.
2. Spider-Man 2 - No other Marvel movie has more heart. From an emotional standpoint, this is an incredible film.
Highlight - The Train Sequence
3. Captain America: The Winter
Soldier - Mature tone, spy-genre sensibility and a great ensemble cast playing out a resonant story.
Highlights - Robert Redford as Alexander Pierce. The breathtaking design of S.H.I.E.L.D.'s headquarters, the Triskelion.
4.
Spider-Man - A remarkably pitch-perfect comic book film, translating the aesthetic and fun straight off of the page and onto the screen.
Highlight - J.K. Simmons as J. Jonah Jameson, a comic book character brought brilliantly to life if ever there was one.
5.
Hulk - Under appreciated and a bit on the weird side, but few superhero films have ever been so thoughtful and ambitious.
Highlights - The incredible combination of sets, cinematography and editing. The psychological depth of the story.
6.
Iron Man - Tight, concise and surging with charisma. This was a masterstroke for Marvel Studios.
Highlight - Robert Downey, Jr. as Tony Stark.
7.
X-Men: First Class - A great spread of back-story and foundation, wrapped in fab 1960's historical fiction.
Highlights - The set and costume design. Arguably the best climactic set-piece of any film on this list.
8.
X-Men - A strong, character-driven foundation for modern, serious comic book films.
Highlights - Phenomenal, diverse casting. The Wolverine-Rogue subplot.
9.
Thor - The perfect approach to this character, techno-Vikings and science geeks, given Shakespearean flair by the perfect director, Kenneth Branagh.
Highlights - Chris Hemsworth and Tom Hiddleston as Thor and Loki, respectively. The gorgeous visual design of Asgard.
10. T
he Wolverine - Dark, stripped-down and visceral. If it weren't for the inconsistent ending, this would be ranked
much higher. (I still have not seen the
Unleashed Extended Edition, which is reputedly a better version.)
Highlight - Rila Fukushima as Yukio.
11.
Iron Man 3 - A very satisfying end to its trilogy, with a great mix of pathos, action and humor. The 'Mandarin twist' is divisive, but I loved it. How often do you get a true surprise in one of these films?
Highlight -
The Air Force One Rescue Sequence
12.
Captain America: The First
Avenger - Lovingly constructed and wonderfully earnest, although it plays as a bit of a montage. Marvel Studios crammed quite a bit into this film.
Highlights - Chris Evans and Hayley Atwell as Steve Rogers and Peggy Carter, respectively, both separately and together.
13.
The Avengers - No other film is as much fun, or quite the same team-building landmark. Still, the plot and climactic villains (the Chitauri) both strike me as sub-par. This is an instance of sheer charisma covering the weaknesses. But there are weaknesses.
Highlight - The witty, endlessly entertaining banter between the characters.
14.
The Incredible Hulk - A solid take on the character, but in over-correcting for
Hulk's weirdness, this film limited itself to the relatively mundane.
Highlight - Edward Norton in the lead role.
15.
Spider-Man 3 - Overstuffed with villains and plot lines, and not a little bit crazy, but satisfying and spiritually consistent nonetheless.
Highlights - Thomas Hayden Church as Flint Marco/Sandman. Also, the emo Peter Parker dance sequence, because sometimes there's nothing better than taking a step into the bizarre.
16.
Iron Man 2 - Disjointed as an overall film, but enjoyable in spite of its unevenness.
Highlight - The Howard Stark/World's Fair/New Element plot device, a very inspiring conception, even if a bit clumsy in execution.
17.
X-Men: The Last Stand - A decent film in its own right, but a drastic drop in quality and change in tone from the first two
X-Men films.
Highlights - Ummm...I suppose, the final teaser scene with Magneto. Otherwise, there just is not a lot to choose from here.
18.
Daredevil (Director’s Cut) - An odd combination of gritty and downright whimsical. The net result is, to me, somewhat less than compelling.
Highlights - The small pleasures, such as the design of Matt Murdock's apartment and Ellen Pompeo (Meredith Grey herself) as legal secretary Karen Page.
19.
Fantastic Four - Fun, lively and easy-viewing family entertainment. Also campy, unfortunately, and a decidedly underachieving representation of the source material.
Highlights - Chris Evans and Michael Chiklis are superbly cast as Johnny Storm and Ben Grimm, respectively. A pity that the rest of the cast is not so pitch-perfect.
20.
Fantastic Four: Rise of the
Silver Surfer - A reasonably thoughtful, dynamic sequel. Same basic issues as its predecessor, though.
Highlights - Laurence Fishburne as the voice of the Silver Surfer. Also, I'm going to break with the common consensus and say that the "space cloud" depiction of Galactus was a good idea and makes sense.
21.
The Amazing Spider-Man - Fantastic first twenty minutes. This should have been incredible - just
look at that killer cool poster art. But the producers neglected the story, and that is the cardinal sin.
Over the course of two hours, this film devolves from a promising reboot into an unrealized, lesser imitation of
Spider-Man 1 and
2. A pity.
Highlight - The outstanding cast.
22.
Thor: The Dark World - A stakes-raising sequel with no true drama and an almost complete absence of substantive character development. Nothing about this film is egregiously bad, but it's difficult to find anything especially good, either.
Highlight - The eye contact shared between Jane Foster and Sif as they walk past each other in Asgard. Unfortunately, this dynamic is given mere seconds of onscreen insinuation. There is romantic drama (with a potentially fascinating love triangle) waiting in the wings, but it goes mostly unexplored.
23.
X-Men Origins: Wolverine - A disjointed feature-length montage full of ludicrous, over-the-top action sequences and disappointing character portrayals.
Highlight - The sparse, beautiful Canada sequence with Lynn Collins as Kayla Silverfox. That part of the film should have been the template for its entirely, and indeed looks forward to the more intimate tone of the vastly superior
The Wolverine.
<>